MP Estate Planning UK

Challenge to a Will: Our Guide to Protecting Your Family’s Assets

Having a valid Will is crucial for every adult, as it ensures that your wishes are respected after you’re gone. If you pass away without a Will, you’re considered to have died “intestate,” which means your estate will be distributed according to the rigid intestacy rules set out in English and Welsh law — rules that often don’t reflect what you would have wanted. At MP Estate Planning, we understand the importance of protecting your family’s assets and guiding you through the process of estate planning.

Contesting a will can be a complex and emotionally taxing process. However, with the right guidance, you can ensure that your loved ones are protected and your inheritance is safeguarded. We specialise in providing expert advice on challenging a will and broader estate protection strategies, helping you understand the legal framework and the options available to you.

Key Takeaways

  • Understand the importance of having a valid Will to avoid intestacy and the default distribution rules.
  • Learn how to protect your family’s assets through effective estate planning, including the use of lifetime trusts.
  • Discover the steps involved in contesting a will in England and Wales.
  • Get insights into the legal grounds for challenging a will, including testamentary capacity, undue influence, and improper execution.
  • Find out how proactive planning — such as placing assets into trust — can reduce the risk of will disputes arising in the first place.

Understanding a Challenge to a Will

Contesting a will is a serious legal matter that requires a thorough understanding of the grounds for a valid challenge. When a loved one passes away, their will can become a point of contention among family members — particularly if they feel the will does not accurately reflect the deceased’s wishes, or if they have been unfairly left out of the estate.

In England and Wales, there are specific legal grounds on which a will can be challenged. These include lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, improper execution, fraud or forgery, and a lack of knowledge and approval. Separately, under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, certain individuals can claim that the will does not make reasonable financial provision for them — even if the will itself is technically valid. We’ll explore these grounds in detail below.

What Constitutes a Valid Challenge?

A valid challenge to a will is based on specific legal grounds recognised in English and Welsh law. Lack of testamentary capacity is one such ground, meaning that the deceased did not have the mental capacity to make a valid will at the time it was executed. The test for testamentary capacity comes from the historic case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870) and requires that the person understood the nature of making a will, the extent of their estate, and the claims of those who might expect to benefit.

Undue influence is another ground, where it is believed that someone coerced the deceased into making a will that did not reflect their true wishes. Unlike some other areas of English law, undue influence in the context of wills must be proved — it is not presumed, even in relationships of trust and dependency. Improper execution refers to the will not meeting the requirements of the Wills Act 1837 — namely, that it must be in writing, signed by the testator (or by someone at their direction and in their presence), and witnessed by two independent witnesses who were both present at the same time.

  • Lack of testamentary capacity
  • Undue influence or coercion
  • Improper execution under the Wills Act 1837
  • Fraud or forgery
  • Lack of knowledge and approval
  • Claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975

Common Grounds for Contesting a Will

Understanding the common grounds for contesting a will can help clarify whether you have a valid reason to challenge a will. The following table summarises these grounds:

Grounds for ContestingDescription
Lack of Testamentary CapacityThe deceased lacked the mental capacity to understand the nature of making a will, the extent of their estate, and the claims of potential beneficiaries (the Banks v Goodfellow test).
Undue InfluenceThe deceased was coerced or pressured into making a will that did not reflect their true wishes. This must be positively proved by the person making the allegation.
Improper ExecutionThe will was not signed or witnessed correctly in accordance with the Wills Act 1837.

 

By understanding these grounds, you can better assess your situation and decide on the best course of action. Contesting a will is a complex process, and knowing your legal standing is crucial before committing time and resources to a challenge.

Legal Grounds for Contesting a Will

Understanding the legal grounds for contesting a will is crucial for protecting your family’s assets. When a will is contested in England and Wales, the court’s primary concern is whether the will is valid and represents the deceased’s true intentions. The burden of proof varies depending on the type of challenge being made.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

A key ground for contesting a will is the lack of testamentary capacity. Under the Banks v Goodfellow test, the testator must have understood the nature of making a will and its effects, the extent of the property being disposed of, and the claims of those who might reasonably expect to benefit. They must also not have been suffering from any disorder of the mind that influenced their decisions in making the will.

To illustrate, consider the case where an elderly person, known to have a history of dementia or cognitive decline, makes a will that significantly deviates from their previously expressed wishes — for example, suddenly cutting out children they had always intended to provide for. In such a scenario, it might be argued that they lacked the mental capacity to understand the implications of their actions. Medical evidence — including GP records, hospital notes, and specialist assessments — would be critical in establishing this claim.

Undue Influence

Another significant ground for contesting a will is undue influence. This occurs when someone coerces the testator into making a will that does not reflect their true wishes. Importantly, in English law, undue influence in relation to wills must be positively proved — it is not presumed, even where there was a relationship of dependency between the testator and the alleged influencer.

For example, if a live-in carer has significant control over the deceased’s daily life and access to visitors, and the deceased then makes a will leaving a substantial portion of their estate to this carer at the expense of close family members, it might be contested on the grounds of undue influence. Evidence such as isolation of the testator from family, control of their communications, or suspicious circumstances surrounding the drafting of the will would be relevant.

Improper Execution

Improper execution refers to the failure to follow the legal formalities required under the Wills Act 1837 for a will to be considered valid. In England and Wales, the will must be in writing, signed by the testator (or by another person in their presence and at their direction), and the testator’s signature must be made or acknowledged in the presence of two witnesses who are both present at the same time. Both witnesses must then sign the will. Crucially, the witnesses — and their spouses or civil partners — must not be beneficiaries under the will, or they risk losing their entitlement.

Grounds for ContestingDescriptionExample
Lack of Testamentary CapacityThe deceased lacked the mental ability to understand the nature and effect of making a willElderly person with diagnosed dementia making an unexpected will that contradicts long-held wishes
Undue InfluenceSomeone coerced the deceased into making a will that did not reflect their true wishesLive-in carer isolating the deceased and benefiting significantly under a new will
Improper ExecutionFailure to follow the formalities required by the Wills Act 1837Will not witnessed by two people simultaneously, or witness is also a beneficiary

By understanding these legal grounds, individuals can better navigate the complex process of contesting a will and ensure that their family’s assets are protected. It’s worth noting that a separate — but equally important — route exists under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, which allows eligible claimants to argue that the will (or intestacy) failed to make reasonable financial provision for them, even if the will is otherwise legally valid.

The Process of Contesting a Will

Understanding the process of contesting a will is crucial for those who believe they have been unfairly treated in a loved one’s estate distribution. Contesting a will is a legal process that can be complex and emotionally taxing, but with the right guidance, individuals can navigate this challenging situation effectively.

When a will is contested, the court’s primary concern is to determine whether the will is valid or if there are grounds for it to be challenged. This process involves several key steps, including entering a caveat at the Probate Registry, potentially filing a challenge in court, and adhering to specific time limits.

Filing a Challenge in Court

The first practical step in many will disputes is to enter a caveat at the Probate Registry. A caveat prevents the Grant of Probate from being issued for six months (and can be renewed), which effectively freezes the estate administration and gives you time to investigate your claim and take legal advice. If the dispute cannot be resolved, it may proceed to court — typically the Chancery Division of the High Court or, for Inheritance Act claims, the County Court or High Court depending on the value of the estate.

It is essential to have legal representation during this process to ensure that all necessary documentation is correctly prepared and filed. The court’s role is to examine the evidence presented and determine the validity of the will. This may involve reviewing the will itself, assessing the mental capacity of the deceased at the time of writing the will, and considering any evidence of undue influence or improper execution.

StepDescriptionTimeline
Entering a CaveatFiling a caveat at the Probate Registry to prevent the Grant of Probate being issued. Valid for six months and renewable.Can be done immediately upon learning of the death
Issuing a ClaimIf the dispute is not resolved, formal court proceedings are issued setting out the grounds of the challenge.Depends on the type of claim — see time limits below
Court Proceedings and ResolutionThe court examines the evidence and makes a decision on the validity of the will or the provision to be made.Several months to over a year, depending on complexity

Time Limits for Contesting a Will

There are strict time limits for contesting a will in England and Wales, and these vary depending on the type of claim. For claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, the claim must typically be made within six months of the date the Grant of Probate (or Letters of Administration) is issued. The court does have discretion to allow late claims, but permission is not guaranteed, and you would need to demonstrate a good reason for the delay.

For challenges based on the validity of the will itself — such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, or improper execution — there is no fixed statutory time limit, but it is critical to act as quickly as possible. Entering a caveat early is essential to prevent the estate from being distributed before your challenge can be heard.

We understand that contesting a will can be a daunting and emotionally charged process. Our role is to guide you through the legal complexities, ensuring that your rights are protected and that you receive the support you need during this challenging time.

Evidence Required for a Successful Challenge

The outcome of a will contest largely depends on the evidence submitted to the court. To successfully challenge a will, it’s crucial to present robust evidence that supports your claim — and the type of evidence needed will depend on the grounds you are relying upon.

When contesting a will based on its validity (testamentary capacity, undue influence, or improper execution), the burden of proof may shift depending on the circumstances. If the will appears regular on its face and was prepared with professional legal advice, the person challenging it bears the burden of proving it is invalid. However, if there are “suspicious circumstances” — for instance, the main beneficiary was closely involved in the preparation of the will — the burden may shift to those seeking to uphold the will to prove it was properly made.

Types of Evidence You May Need

Several types of evidence can be used to support a claim when contesting a will. These include:

  • Witness statements: Testimonies from individuals who knew the deceased or were present when the will was signed can be invaluable. The attesting witnesses to the will are often the first port of call.
  • Medical records: GP notes, hospital records, and specialist assessments that demonstrate the deceased’s mental state around the time the will was made. This is particularly important for capacity challenges.
  • Solicitor’s attendance notes: If the will was prepared by a solicitor, their file notes regarding the testator’s instructions and mental state can be critical evidence — often referred to as the “golden rule” evidence if a capacity assessment was carried out.
  • Correspondence: Letters, emails, text messages, or other communications that may indicate the deceased’s true intentions, their state of mind, or any pressure being applied by a third party.
  • Financial records: Evidence of the deceased’s financial situation, particularly where there are allegations of financial abuse or suspicious transactions leading up to the new will.

contesting a will evidence

The Role of Witnesses in Will Disputes

Witnesses play a significant role in will disputes, as their testimonies can provide firsthand accounts of the circumstances surrounding the signing of the will. The two attesting witnesses are often key — they can confirm whether the testator appeared to understand what they were signing, whether they signed voluntarily, and whether the formalities of execution were properly followed.

Reliable witnesses beyond the attesting witnesses can also strengthen your case. Family members, friends, neighbours, and professional carers who had regular contact with the deceased around the time the will was made can provide valuable evidence about the testator’s mental state, their relationships, and any changes in behaviour. It’s essential to identify and prepare witnesses who can provide clear, consistent, and credible testimony.

The Impact of a Will Challenge on Family Dynamics

When a will is challenged, the repercussions can be far-reaching, affecting family dynamics in profound ways. Contesting a will is not just a legal matter; it’s a deeply personal and emotional experience that can strain relationships, create lasting divisions, and alter family bonds for generations.

Navigating Family Relationships

Disputing a will can lead to complex family conflicts, as different members may have varying opinions on the validity of the will or the fairness of its provisions. Siblings who were once close may find themselves on opposite sides of a legal dispute. This can result in a deeply divided family, with some members supporting the challenge and others opposing it — sometimes on the same grounds but with different interpretations of the deceased’s wishes.

The emotional toll of contesting a will should not be underestimated. Family members may experience feelings of betrayal, anger, grief, and guilt, which can be challenging to navigate alongside the legal process. It’s essential to approach these situations with empathy and understanding, recognising that grief affects people differently.

Key considerations when navigating family relationships during a will challenge:

  • Maintain open and honest communication where possible, even if views differ
  • Seek emotional support from trusted friends, family, or a counsellor
  • Consider professional mediation before resorting to court proceedings — it’s often quicker, cheaper, and less destructive to relationships

Mediation as an Alternative

Mediation offers a viable alternative to litigation when disputing a will. This process involves a neutral third-party mediator who helps family members negotiate and work towards a mutually acceptable agreement. Courts in England and Wales actively encourage mediation in inheritance disputes, and refusing to engage in mediation without good reason can sometimes result in adverse costs orders — even if you ultimately win your case.

The benefits of mediation include reduced conflict, significant cost savings compared to litigation, and a faster resolution. It allows families to maintain a degree of control over the outcome, rather than leaving the decision entirely in a judge’s hands. Mediation is confidential, unlike court proceedings which can become a matter of public record. It’s a process that can help families navigate the challenges of disputing a will in a more constructive and less adversarial manner.

AspectLitigationMediation
CostHigh legal fees — will disputes can cost tens of thousands of poundsSignificantly lower costs, typically a fraction of litigation
TimeCan take one to three years or more to reach a final hearingOften resolved in one or two sessions over a few weeks
Relationship ImpactAdversarial by nature, often causing permanent damage to family relationshipsPromotes dialogue and collaboration, helping to preserve relationships
PrivacyCourt proceedings are generally a matter of public recordConfidential — discussions and outcomes remain private

Alternatives to Contesting a Will

Before taking the matter to court, it’s worth exploring alternatives to contesting a will. Litigation can be lengthy, expensive, and emotionally draining, and there are often more constructive ways to resolve disputes that preserve family relationships and reduce costs.

Considerations for Negotiating

Negotiation is a viable alternative to contesting a will. It involves discussing the contents of the will with the relevant parties — typically the executors and other beneficiaries — to reach a mutually agreeable solution. In England and Wales, beneficiaries can agree to vary the terms of a will using a Deed of Variation (also known as a Deed of Family Arrangement), provided all affected beneficiaries agree and the deed is executed within two years of the death. This can redirect assets without the need for any court involvement at all.

  • Identify the key issues causing the dispute — is it about fairness, a specific asset, or a perceived broken promise?
  • Consider the interests and needs of all parties involved, not just the legal positions.
  • Be prepared to compromise on certain aspects — the cost and uncertainty of litigation often mean a negotiated outcome is better for everyone.

Negotiation can be facilitated by a neutral third party, such as a mediator, who can help guide the discussions towards a resolution without the need for a court to impose one.

The Role of Family Meetings

Family meetings can play a crucial role in resolving inheritance disputes. By bringing together all relevant family members, these meetings provide a platform for open discussion about the will and any concerns or grievances before they escalate into formal legal proceedings.

A successful family meeting requires careful planning, including setting a clear agenda, choosing a neutral venue, and ensuring that all parties have an opportunity to express their views. It’s important to maintain a respectful and constructive atmosphere during the meeting. In some cases, having an independent professional — such as a mediator or solicitor — present to facilitate the discussion can help keep conversations productive and focused.

inheritance dispute resolution

By considering alternatives to contesting a will, such as negotiation, Deeds of Variation, and family meetings, individuals can often find a more amicable and less costly resolution to inheritance disputes.

Engaging Legal Representation

Engaging a solicitor with expertise in will disputes is crucial for a successful outcome when challenging a will. We understand that navigating the complexities of a will challenge can be daunting, which is why having the right legal representation is vital.

When to Hire a Solicitor

You should consider hiring a solicitor as soon as you suspect there may be grounds to contest a will. Given the strict time limits — particularly the six-month deadline for Inheritance Act claims from the date of the Grant of Probate — early engagement can significantly impact the outcome of your case. A solicitor can enter a caveat at the Probate Registry on your behalf, preventing the Grant from being issued while you investigate your claim.

For instance, a solicitor can assist in obtaining the deceased’s medical records, requesting the will file from the drafting solicitor, gathering witness statements, and preparing your case, ensuring that you have a strong foundation for your challenge. The sooner you take professional advice, the more options are likely to be available to you.

How to Choose the Right Legal Expert

Choosing the right solicitor involves considering their experience in handling will disputes and their knowledge of contentious probate law. We recommend looking for a solicitor who specialises in contentious probate — this is a distinct area of legal practice, and general practice solicitors may not have the specialist expertise needed for complex will disputes. As Mike Pugh often says, “The law — like medicine — is broad. You wouldn’t want your GP doing surgery.”

  • Check their credentials and specific experience in handling will disputes and Inheritance Act claims.
  • Assess their understanding of the legal grounds for contesting a will and the types of evidence required.
  • Ask about their approach to costs — do they offer fixed fees, hourly rates, or conditional fee arrangements?
  • Consider their ability to communicate effectively and provide clear, jargon-free guidance throughout the process.

The Costs Involved in Challenging a Will

When considering contesting a will, understanding the financial implications is crucial. Challenging a will can be a costly process, involving legal fees, court costs, and other expenses. It’s essential to be aware of these costs to make an informed decision about whether to proceed — and if so, how to fund your claim.

Breakdown of Potential Expenses

The expenses associated with contesting a will can be significant, and costs can escalate quickly if the matter proceeds to a full hearing. Some of the key costs include:

  • Legal Fees: Solicitors’ fees vary widely depending on their experience, their location, and the complexity of the case. Specialist contentious probate solicitors may charge higher hourly rates but can often resolve matters more efficiently.
  • Court Fees: These include fees for issuing a claim at court and other procedural costs throughout the proceedings.
  • Expert Witness Fees: In capacity challenges, you may need a retrospective medical assessment from a specialist, such as a consultant psychiatrist, which can add several thousand pounds to the overall cost.
  • Mediation Costs: If the court directs mediation (or you choose it voluntarily), there will be a mediator’s fee, though this is typically far less than the cost of a court hearing.
  • Adverse Costs Risk: In England and Wales, the losing party in litigation can be ordered to pay the winning party’s reasonable legal costs. This is a significant financial risk that must be carefully weighed before issuing proceedings.

It’s vital to discuss these potential expenses with your solicitor at the outset to understand the likely total cost involved in contesting a will and the range of possible outcomes.

Funding Options for Legal Challenges

Funding a legal challenge can be a significant concern. There are several options to consider:

  • Private Funding: Using personal savings or assets to cover legal costs. This gives you full control but carries the financial risk if the claim is unsuccessful.
  • Before-the-Event Legal Expenses Insurance: Check your existing home insurance policies — many include legal expenses cover that may extend to inheritance disputes, though this cover must typically have been in place before the dispute arose.
  • Conditional Fee Agreements (CFAs): Also known as ‘no win, no fee’ agreements, where the solicitor’s fees are contingent on the outcome of the case. If successful, the solicitor charges a “success fee” (a percentage uplift on their normal fees). Not all firms offer CFAs for will disputes, and they are more commonly available for stronger claims.
  • Third-Party Litigation Funding: In some higher-value cases, a litigation funder may agree to fund the legal challenge in exchange for a share of any recovery. This is typically only available for claims with a high prospect of success and a significant estate value.

Each funding option has its advantages and disadvantages, and it’s crucial to carefully consider these before making a decision. We recommend consulting with a specialist contentious probate solicitor to discuss your specific situation, the merits of your claim, and the most appropriate funding route.

Preventing Will Challenges

Clear communication and proper drafting are key to preventing will challenges — but truly robust estate planning goes further than the will itself. Many will challenges arise from misunderstandings, ambiguous wording, or the perception that a family member has been unfairly treated. Taking proactive steps during your lifetime can dramatically reduce the risk of disputes after your death.

Importance of Clear Communication

Effective communication is crucial in preventing will disputes. It’s not just about drafting a will; it’s about ensuring that your family understands the reasoning behind your decisions. Clear communication can help prevent misunderstandings and reduce the likelihood of a will being challenged. We recommend discussing the broad outline of your estate plan with your family and beneficiaries to address any concerns or questions they may have — particularly if your plans include unequal distributions or the exclusion of someone who might expect to inherit.

While you are under no legal obligation to share the contents of your will, having an open conversation can remove the element of surprise that so often triggers disputes. A letter of wishes — a non-binding document explaining the reasoning behind your decisions — can also be extremely helpful for your executors and beneficiaries.

Proper Will Drafting Practices

Proper will drafting is fundamental to preventing challenges. A well-drafted will should be clear, specific, and unambiguous. It’s essential to ensure that the will is executed correctly in accordance with the Wills Act 1837, with two independent witnesses present at the same time. Using a specialist solicitor or experienced estate planner — rather than a DIY kit or generic online service — significantly reduces the risk of errors.

To minimise the risk of a will challenge, consider the following best practices:

  • Ensure the will is written in clear and precise language, avoiding vague phrases like “my personal effects” without definition.
  • Include specific details about the distribution of assets and name beneficiaries clearly.
  • If there is any concern about testamentary capacity, have the testator assessed by a medical professional at the time of making the will — this is known as the “golden rule” and provides strong evidence of capacity.
  • Appoint executors who are trustworthy, capable, and ideally have no conflict of interest.
  • Review and update the will regularly — particularly after major life events such as marriage, divorce, the birth of children or grandchildren, or a significant change in assets.
  • Consider placing key assets — such as the family home — into a lifetime trust, which removes them from the will entirely and therefore from the scope of most will challenges. Assets held in trust are managed by trustees and are not part of the probate estate.

For more information on why avoiding cheap wills is crucial, visit our page on why you should avoid cheap wills in the UK.

Best PracticeBenefit
Clear and precise languageReduces ambiguity and misunderstandings that can trigger challenges
Specific asset distributionMinimises disputes over asset division and leaves no room for interpretation
Medical capacity assessmentProvides strong evidence of testamentary capacity if later challenged
Trustworthy executorsEnsures the will is administered properly and impartially
Regular reviews and updatesReflects changes in circumstances, relationships, and wishes
Placing assets into a lifetime trustRemoves assets from the probate estate, reducing the scope for will challenges

The Role of Executors in a Will Challenge

Executors bear significant responsibilities when a will challenge arises, requiring a delicate balance between legal compliance, impartiality, and sensitivity to family dynamics. As the individuals tasked with administering the estate, executors must navigate the complexities of a will contest while upholding their duty to carry out the deceased’s wishes as expressed in the will.

Responsibilities of an Executor

An executor’s role is multifaceted, involving various duties that become even more demanding during a will challenge. These include:

  • Safeguarding and managing the estate’s assets during the dispute
  • Communicating with beneficiaries, claimants, and other stakeholders
  • Defending the will against challenges — executors have a duty to uphold the will unless there is a good reason not to
  • Ensuring compliance with legal requirements, including the proper administration of the estate
  • Taking legal advice from a specialist contentious probate solicitor at the estate’s expense

Executors must act impartially and in the best interests of the estate as a whole, which can be particularly challenging when they are also a beneficiary or a family member. Effective communication and transparency are key to managing the expectations of beneficiaries and minimising the escalation of disputes. An executor who is perceived as biased or secretive can inadvertently fuel challenges.

How Executors Can Prepare for Challenges

Preparation is vital for executors to navigate a will challenge successfully. This includes:

  1. Understanding the will thoroughly: Familiarity with the will’s contents and any accompanying letter of wishes can help executors explain the deceased’s reasoning to beneficiaries and defend against challenges.
  2. Gathering and preserving evidence: Collecting relevant documentation — including the solicitor’s file notes, medical records, and correspondence — to support the will’s validity is crucial, and should be done promptly before evidence is lost or destroyed.
  3. Seeking specialist legal advice early: Engaging with a solicitor experienced in contentious probate can provide executors with the necessary guidance on how to respond to a challenge, what information to disclose, and when to consider mediation or settlement.
  4. Not distributing the estate prematurely: If there is any possibility of a challenge, executors should not distribute assets until the dispute is resolved or the time limits have passed, as they could be personally liable for any loss.

By being proactive and informed, executors can better manage the challenges associated with contesting a will, ensuring that the estate is administered according to the deceased’s wishes while treating all parties fairly. In cases of inheritance dispute, maintaining a calm and professional demeanour is essential for resolving conflicts and protecting the executor from personal criticism or legal liability.

Conclusion: Protecting Your Family’s Legacy

Understanding the complexities of challenging a will is crucial for protecting your family’s assets and ensuring a secure legacy for your loved ones. By grasping the grounds for a valid challenge and the process of contesting a will in England and Wales, you can navigate potential will disputes effectively — or better yet, take steps to prevent them from arising in the first place.

Key Considerations for Families

Families facing a will dispute must consider the legal grounds for challenging a will, such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, or improper execution, as well as potential claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Clear communication, proper will drafting, and a medical capacity assessment at the time of making the will are all essential in preventing challenges. Additionally, proactive estate planning — such as placing key assets into a discretionary lifetime trust — can remove those assets from the scope of most will disputes entirely, as trust assets are held by trustees and do not pass through the will or the probate process.

Preparing for the Future

To safeguard your family’s future, it’s vital to engage in thorough estate planning. This includes drafting a clear and properly executed will, communicating your wishes to your loved ones, regularly reviewing your estate plan after major life events, and seeking professional legal advice. As Mike Pugh often says, “Plan, don’t panic.” By taking these steps now — whether that’s putting a robust will in place, establishing a Family Home Protection Trust, or simply having an honest conversation with your family — you can minimise the risk of a will dispute and ensure that your legacy is protected for the people who matter most.

FAQ

What are the grounds for contesting a will?

The main grounds for contesting a will in England and Wales include lack of testamentary capacity (the Banks v Goodfellow test), undue influence or coercion, improper execution under the Wills Act 1837, fraud or forgery, and lack of knowledge and approval. Separately, eligible individuals can make a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 if the will does not make reasonable financial provision for them.

How do I contest a will?

The first practical step is usually to enter a caveat at the Probate Registry, which prevents the Grant of Probate from being issued for six months and gives you time to investigate your claim. You should seek legal advice from a solicitor who specialises in contentious probate as early as possible. If the dispute cannot be resolved through negotiation or mediation, formal court proceedings may be issued.

What evidence is required to support a successful challenge to a will?

The evidence required depends on the grounds of your challenge. For capacity claims, medical records and GP notes are often essential. Witness statements from those who knew the deceased or were present at the signing of the will are important for many types of challenge. The solicitor’s attendance notes and file, financial records, and correspondence can also be critical. The stronger and more detailed your evidence, the better your prospects.

Can contesting a will affect family dynamics?

Yes, contesting a will can have a significant and lasting impact on family dynamics. Disputes can divide families and cause lasting damage to relationships. This is why alternative dispute resolution methods — particularly mediation — are strongly encouraged by courts in England and Wales. Mediation is confidential, less adversarial, and often produces better outcomes for family relationships than contested court proceedings.

Are there alternatives to contesting a will?

Yes, there are several alternatives. Negotiation between beneficiaries and executors can often resolve disputes without court proceedings. A Deed of Variation allows beneficiaries to agree to change the distribution of the estate within two years of the death. Family meetings facilitated by a neutral party can also help resolve grievances. Mediation is another highly effective option that courts actively encourage.

When should I hire a solicitor to contest a will?

You should seek legal advice as soon as you suspect there may be grounds to contest a will. Given that Inheritance Act claims must typically be brought within six months of the Grant of Probate being issued, early action is critical. A specialist contentious probate solicitor can advise you on the merits of your claim, enter a caveat to protect your position, and guide you through the process.

What are the costs involved in challenging a will?

The costs can vary significantly depending on the complexity of the case and whether it settles early or proceeds to a full court hearing. Costs may include solicitors’ fees, court fees, expert witness fees (particularly for medical capacity assessments), and mediation costs. There is also the risk of adverse costs — if you lose, you may be ordered to pay the other side’s legal costs. Funding options include private funding, legal expenses insurance, conditional fee agreements (‘no win, no fee’), and, in higher-value cases, third-party litigation funding.

How can I minimise the risk of a will challenge?

To minimise the risk, ensure your will is drafted by a specialist solicitor or experienced estate planner and properly executed under the Wills Act 1837. If there is any concern about capacity, have a medical assessment carried out at the time of making the will. Communicate your wishes to your family, consider writing a letter of wishes explaining your reasoning, review your will regularly, and consider placing key assets into a lifetime trust — which removes them from the probate estate and the scope of most will challenges.

What is the role of an executor in a will challenge?

The executor has a duty to uphold the will and administer the estate in accordance with the deceased’s wishes. When a challenge arises, the executor should seek specialist legal advice, preserve all relevant evidence, communicate transparently with beneficiaries and claimants, and avoid distributing any assets until the dispute is resolved. Executors can use estate funds to obtain legal advice and representation in defending the will.

What is the time limit for disputing a will or contesting a will?

For claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, the claim must normally be made within six months of the date the Grant of Probate or Letters of Administration is issued. The court does have discretion to allow late claims, but this is not guaranteed. For challenges to the validity of the will itself (capacity, undue influence, improper execution), there is no fixed statutory time limit, but you should act as quickly as possible — entering a caveat at the Probate Registry is an important first step to prevent the estate being distributed.

Can I dispute probate?

Yes, you can dispute probate if you have valid grounds to do so. This might involve entering a caveat at the Probate Registry to prevent the Grant of Probate from being issued, or it might involve challenging the grant after it has been issued. Common reasons include concerns about the validity of the will, fraud, or the suitability of the appointed executor. It is essential to seek legal advice from a specialist contentious probate solicitor to understand your options and the process involved.

How can I resolve an inheritance dispute?

Resolving an inheritance dispute can be complex, but there are several routes available. Negotiation between the parties — potentially facilitated by solicitors — is often the first step. A Deed of Variation may be appropriate if all beneficiaries agree to a different distribution. Mediation is strongly encouraged by the courts and can be highly effective. If these methods fail, formal court proceedings may be necessary. We always recommend seeking specialist legal advice early to understand your options, protect your rights, and give yourself the best chance of reaching a fair resolution.

How can we
help you?

We’re here to help. Please fill in the form and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can. Or call us on 0117 440 1555.

Important Notice

The content on this website is provided for general information and educational purposes only.

It does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice and should not be relied upon as such.

Every family’s circumstances are different.

Before making any decisions about your estate planning, you should seek professional advice tailored to your specific situation.

MP Estate Planning UK is not a law firm. Trusts are not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

MP Estate Planning UK does not provide regulated financial advice.

We work in conjunction with regulated providers. When required we will introduce Chartered Tax Advisors, Financial Advisors or Solicitors.

Would It Be A Bad Idea To Make A Plan?

Come Join Over 2000 Homeowners, Familes And High Net Worth Individuals In England And Wales Who Took The Steps Early To Protect Their Assets